US Supreme Court denies Apple’s bid to avoid paying $440 million damages in patent fight

The Supreme Court docket declined to look at Apple’s appeal to stay away from having to pay approximately $440 million to know-how licensing company VirnetX (VHC) for violations of its patents.
VirnetX declared a “triumph” around Apple (AAPL) in its statement. Shares of VirnetX elevated noticeably following the ruling, and closed up 12% on a working day when the larger sized inventory market place noticed substantial losses.

Apple declined to comment on the decision.

Apple and VirnetX have been battling in court docket since 2010, when VirnetX sued the tech big in the Jap District Court docket of Texas for violating 4 of its patents with its FaceTime and “VPN on Desire” applications on devices which includes the Iphone and iPad. The patents contain solutions for enabling and securing genuine-time communications above the world-wide-web.

VirnetX is a holding organization that licenses patents for security know-how. In its 2018 annual report (the most the latest 1 obtainable), the firm mentioned it owned 70 patents and patent apps in the United States and mentioned “our portfolio of intellectual home is the foundation of our business design.” VirnetX posted $63,000 in yearly income in 2018.

In 2016, a Texas jury located Apple had infringed on the 4 patents, resulting in a $302 million award for VirnetX (that award is now bigger mainly because of expenses and interest). The US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in Washington upheld that choice in 2019.

Apple then appealed to the Supreme Courtroom, contacting the $440 million in damages “grossly excessive” and proclaiming the award overstated the worth of the patented engineering. Apple also argued that at the very least some of the patents at difficulty in the go well with are no more time legitimate, “leaving Apple on the hook for hundreds of millions of pounds primarily based on invalid promises,” the corporation said in its appeal.

Apple has filed promises with the Patent Trial and Attraction Board hard the patentability of the engineering in all four VirnetX patents. The Board has formally located just one of the 4 patents invalid the other three continue to be in the appeals system.

Now that the Supreme Court has turned down Apple’s attraction of the judgement, the scenario will be sent back to the district court in Texas for the $440 million damages to be enforced.

“We have always believed that we ended up in the appropriate with our court steps versus Apple,” VirnetX CEO Kendall Larsen said in a assertion Monday.

“We imagine that our technology offers an vital protection attribute in some Apple products particularly the Iphone,” he stated. “We consider this (jury award) amount of money is much more than fair thinking of the worth of World-wide-web safety.”

Apple and VirnetX are included in a different ongoing legal dispute, which specials with whether redesigned versions of FaceTime and VPN on Need even now violate the similar VirnetX patents. In this scenario, also, Apple has argued the patent promises are invalid.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *